The Teacher I Never Thanked
Every student remembers a teacher who was hard to love in the moment, the one whose strictness felt personal, until years later it finally made sense. "The Teacher I Never Thanked" follows Ananya's first day of 11th grade, when her new Economics teacher, Mrs Kirti, singles her out for something as small as her open hair. What starts as an awkward first impression grows into months of quiet hurt, as Ananya is constantly picked on and never seems to meet her teacher's expectations, no matter how hard she works. Only on the eve of their final exam does the truth surface: every scolding was deliberate, meant to push her further. This essay reflects on the teachers who challenge us hardest because they see what we can't yet see in ourselves and offers a long-overdue thank you to one of them.
It all started on a fresh, sunny morning of 3rd April, 2023. The first day of 11th grade.
Everyone was extremely excited for the new session to start, since all of us were finally
seniors.
Beginnings are like that. They make us feel hopeful and joyous, giving us a chance to become better and start a new chapter of life in the most perfect way possible. And so, it was for the students of 11-E, the humanities section, naturally landing on the later alphabet, since the science and commerce streams had already claimed A to D. Here we were, all set to study the history, geography, and economics of this beautiful nation.
We were chatting with each other about our well-spent vacations when our class teacher arrived.
The class went silent. We stared at her collectively, trying to guess if she'd be lenient or strict. She sat down at her desk, placed a big yellow attendance register in front of her, and began with the most obvious line of introduction: "Good morning, class. I am Mrs Kirti, and I am your class teacher for this session. I will be teaching you Economics." We were in awe. Economics, we'd been told, was the hardest subject in the humanities stream. We were equally excited and scared, because she had a reputation for being strict. Our seniors had warned us that her students had been humiliated over the smallest things, like using a black pen instead of a blue one in her assignments. As she looked at each of our faces, as if trying to memorise them all in one glance, her eyes landed on me. I was sitting on the third bench in the middle row, the safest bench, in student language. I wasn't confident enough to sit up front and look studious, but I wasn't bold enough to sit at the back either. The third bench was for average students like me: willing to push ourselves to become our best version, but not quite ready to take that leap of faith.
She pointed at me instantly. "You."
I looked around at my benchmates, hoping she meant someone else.
"You, the girl with the open hair. What's your name?"
"Ananya, ma'am."
"Ananya, why is your hair open? Do you not know the rules of this school?"
"Ma'am, my hair is too short to tie into a ponytail. I have to leave it open."
She made an expression that told me she wasn't satisfied with my answer, but she let it go. I was mortified, not exactly the first impression I'd hoped to make.
Over the next few days, as she got to know us, we realised she really was strict but not in a
way that made us afraid of her. Her strictness was unpredictable. No one could tell what
might set her off, so we all walked on eggshells around her. But she was also a fabulous
teacher. Economics had never been easier for us; it was as though she'd invented the subject
herself. She was reserved, rarely speaking to us beyond academics, but she always pushed us to take part in school competitions. She wanted 11-E to be the best class in school and, thanks to her, we did end up winning Best Class of the Year on Annual Day. But that wasn't the whole story.
She had a habit of picking on me almost every day, for one reason or another, until I started to believe she simply didn't like me. In my first test, I scored 20 out of 20 in Economics. She seemed pleased, and even told my father I was a good student but added that I could still do better. Better? I didn't understand how. It stung, mostly because I couldn't figure out why she'd said it. In the days that followed, she always called on me in class, more than anyone else. It wasn't that I wasn't trying; I did my homework on time, studied extra material to stay ahead of my peers, and even prepared notes on chapters we hadn't reached yet, just so my teachers could review and guide me further. Within two months, I was the top-performing student in my class, known across sections for my grades and my involvement in school activities.
Still, I couldn't understand why Kirti ma'am was never satisfied. Why did she scold me over small things like not tying my hair up, stumbling on a question about "marginal utility," or failing to explain why the Indian rupee was weaker than the US dollar? I studied as hard as I could, but I never seemed to impress her. Once, while assigning topics for our winter vacation project, a piece of work worth a major chunk of our final grade, she told the class the topics had been handed out according to each student's ability.
By then, the entire class was aware of the strange dynamic between Kirti ma'am and me. It amused everyone except me. When she began calling out roll numbers, the last-benchers got extremely hard topics like "Abstract Market Behaviour" or "Government and Money Supply." Everyone expected I'd get the hardest one. Instead, she looked me dead in the eye and said, "Ananya Aanand. Solar energy."
Solar energy? Seriously? Even an eighth-grader could handle that. Why would she underestimate me so badly? The class was just as stunned, and a few students even laughed.
This went on for the rest of the session, until final exams arrived.
The day before our Economics exam, Kirti ma'am didn't teach us at all. Instead, she told us how she believed each of us carried a special flame within us, how proud she was of the class we'd become. Then she said something that silenced the room: "But there is one student who has proved me wrong, again and again, and has made me prouder than I can say."
We all went quiet, waiting for the name.
"You. The girl with open hair."
Every head turned toward me. I looked around too, half-expecting she meant someone else. But no, she was pointing at me, just like she had on the very first day. I braced myself for a
scolding.
"Ananya. You are the one who has constantly proved me wrong and exceeded every expectation I had of you. I knew your potential from the very beginning, but I also knew how easily you could break. I knew exactly how much pressure to put on you. There were moments I feared you'd give up under my remarks. But you never did. You kept learning, kept working, and scored the best marks in every single test. I'm sorry if I was too hard on you. But trust me, beta, that's exactly what you needed. I know you'll do wonderfully tomorrow. You are my star student."
Her eyes turned moist as she spoke, and I won't pretend mine stayed dry either. When I got
home, I locked my door, sat on my bed, and let it all sink in.
While everyone else had been busy praising me, she was the only one quietly keeping me
grounded. I had never once considered it from that angle. It's easy, as students, to judge our
teachers, to stop at the surface instead of looking for the bigger picture underneath.
Because of her, I scored 100/100 on my Economics board exam and 99/100 in my 11th grade finals. But the numbers were never really the point.
I never got the chance to tell her, back then, what her strictness meant to me: that being singled out for the "easy" topic wasn't punishment; it was faith in disguise; that every scolding was really her way of refusing to let me settle for good when I was capable of great. I understand it now. I only wish I'd understood it sooner, while I still had the chance to say it to her face.
So, Kirti ma'am, this one's for you, a little late but no less sincere. None of it would have been possible without you.
Thank you, ma'am.
Comments