top of page

Can India Achieve Growth Without Environmental Damage?

14 hours ago
5 min read

The article seeks to discuss this question by focusing on what growth actually means to different people. It argues that development must be inclusive and holistic, and thinking about growth in such terms also helps in dealing with its effects on the environment.


A split-perspective editorial photograph comparing uneven economic growth in urban India: on the left, modern cars drive along a paved highway beneath an elevated concrete flyover and a commercial airplane taking off from a new glass-and-steel airport terminal; on the right, separated by a concrete barrier, local residents walk, push a handcart, and wheel a bicycle along a dusty, unpaved roadside next to cleared land and a small tarp-covered stall.
A commercial airliner ascends above a newly constructed terminal and elevated expressway in India, contrasting sharply with the unpaved, dust-choked roadside just beyond the concrete barrier where daily commuters travel on foot and by bicycle. As rapid infrastructure expansion reshapes the nation’s landscape, policymakers and citizens face a defining question: how to balance economic ambition with environmental resilience and equitable access for all.

Imagine a new airport is being built in your city. It feels like progress is finally coming to your doorstep. You will be more connected to the world. It will be easier to visit your family and friends in other parts of the country and even on other continents! You tell your friend excitedly, “Isn’t it great!” Your friend doesn’t seem to share the enthusiasm. They say, “Sure, but I can’t even afford to buy a two-wheeler right now. I’ve never been on a flight.

And I hope the deforestation for the project doesn’t end up making the air and my mother’s asthma worse.” You’re left conflicted with no clear answers on how to balance economic growth and environmental protection.


It is important to recognize that economic growth often does damage the environment. Even hundreds of years ago, the Industrial Revolution caused widespread habitat loss, deforestation, water and air pollution, and worsened climate change. It’s not hard to look for recent examples, with the town of Joshimath experiencing a land subsidence crisis due to rapid urbanisation. This in part contributed to the devastating effects of the 2021 flash floods by lowering the region’s resilience to such events. When more cars are manufactured and bought, air pollution goes up. Increased production of consumer electronics leads to huge amounts of toxic e-waste. Of course, this is not limited to electronics, and a similar effect can be seen in fast fashion and the fast-moving consumer goods sector, among others. Deforestation follows when many factories, airports, or highways are built.


But, why should the average person care? Isn’t it more important to have roads that people can travel on or factories that they can find jobs at? The truth is environmental damage does not affect everyone the same. And here lies a third part of the puzzle- equity. Just like people living in Joshimath or coastal areas at risk of losing their homes due to sinking land or rising sea levels, many people are more vulnerable to these risks than others. Even more jarring is the fact that the most vulnerable people sometimes contribute the least to the problem. For instance, look at the reality of vehicular pollution and air conditioning. These activities worsen pollution and urban heat. However, people from economically weaker sections, who can neither afford an AC nor a car, face the most severe consequences of these in the form of heatwaves, polluted air, and other dangers they cannot shield themselves from to the extent others can. People who are unable to find adequate food for themselves have more reason to care about land degradation and environmental damage that results in disrupted food chains than a new airport in their vicinity.


Further, we must know that we share this earth with other creatures. There is a certain responsibility that comes with that. Something that cannot be immediately monetized does not lack value. And how do you put a value on a life? Preserving biodiversity and habitats of animals is a duty that we must not abandon.


However, even without resorting to ethical or moral inclinations, the utilitarian perspective offers compelling reasons to be concerned about environmental degradation. Some scholars say that due to environmental degradation, we lose ecosystems and resources that are worth trillions of dollars every year.


Sustainable development is supposed to be growth that meets the needs of people today without hurting the ability of future generations to meet their needs. However, some researchers even consider the phrase “sustainable development” to be an oxymoron. They argue that economic growth, which is one of the most discussed measures of development, often comes with severe environmental impact, which undermines sustainability. It has been found that high human development scores for countries correspond to higher environmental footprints.


So, don’t we want India to score better on human development? When there is more production of goods and services, there are more jobs for people. When people have good jobs and are productive, they can contribute more resources to the country’s development. We can build more schools, hospitals, and invest in other essential services. It is incredibly important to build roads, to build new manufacturing facilities, to invest in basic research and new technologies. Economic growth is important to lift people out of poverty, to raise the standard of living in our country.


So, all this is not to say that we should abandon the aspiration of economic growth. It is not to argue for not building airports or to never use air conditioning. This is just to prompt genuine reflection on the question: can India achieve growth without environmental damage? There are no easy answers to this question. But sitting with the question, with doubt, debate and discussion is so valuable. It gives us a chance to reflect on what we actually consider growth.


What is the difference between growth, development, progress, and urbanisation, building highways, airports, and overall increasing the production of goods and services? One crucial difference is that development is not the same for everyone. Somebody who is struggling for food may benefit from having a more robust, climate-resilient food supply change, while somebody who goes to the office in their car may benefit from new highways. On the other hand, maybe investing in basic science gives better treatment options for certain diseases, benefiting people across the spectrum. But whoever we are, our nation’s definition of growth should include us. We should not leave anyone behind.


Gandhi once said that if one is conflicted about an action, they should “recall the face of the poorest and the weakest man [woman] whom you may have seen, and ask yourself, if the step you contemplate is going to be of any use to him [her]. Will he [she] gain anything by it? Will it restore him [her] to a control over his [her] own life and destiny?”


We must carry this sentiment when we think about what growth means to us. In our holistic conception of growth, we must consider all living creatures, their habitats, and all Indians across communities, across economic strata. This is not just a thought exercise. The chasm between many development projects and the environmental threats they pose plays out in the real world and courtrooms regularly. The Great Nicobar Islands project is a mega- infrastructure venture that will cut through pristine tropical forests. Discussions on this project touched upon the implementation of the Forest Rights Act, environmental degradation, national security, and economic and infrastructural development.


Once we think about holistic development, we can try to push for it. There are ways to achieve this, while also raising the standard of living. Many experts advise on ‘decoupling’ resource-hungry development activities from environmental pressures. For instance, if we focus on renewable energy, we can achieve economic growth without the same environmental effects of using fossil fuels.


If we invest in walkable cities, grassroots education and awareness, and create local ecosystems and food supply chains, we can create jobs as well as realize some aims of environmental protection. We can design circular economies through recycling and other methods, and tackle the waste problem as well as keep up production of goods. If we listen to local voices and indigenous people who are personally devoted to the endurance of ecosystems and forests, then we might have a better chance at arriving at true sustainability.


Does your idea of growth include everyone?

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page